If you were hurt in an accident in Cincinnati, you need a lawyer who knows local courts, has real trial experience, and has a track record you can check. O’Connor, Acciani & Levy stands out with over 30 years in practice, an AV Preeminent peer rating (the highest available), and a 4.7-star average across nearly 1,350 Google reviews. Below, you will find a full breakdown of O’Connor, Acciani & Levy plus three other established Cincinnati firms, so you can compare experience, focus, and contact details in one place.
Contents
At a Glance
| Firm | Founded | Focus | Notable Recognition | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| O’Connor, Acciani & Levy | 1992 | Personal injury, wrongful death, workers’ comp, Social Security Disability | AV Preeminent (2021), multiple Super Lawyers selections | 513-854-1981 |
| Phillips Law Firm, Inc. | 1994 | Personal injury, civil litigation, business law | Super Lawyers recognition, Million Dollar Advocates Forum | 513-985-2500 |
| Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima | 1999 | Personal injury, wrongful death, criminal defense | 200+ years combined experience, multiple multi-million-dollar verdicts | 513-932-7375 |
| Markovits, Stock & DeMarco, LLC | N/A | Personal injury, class actions, complex litigation | Super Lawyers recognition, $2B+ recovered firmwide | 513-651-3700 |
Cincinnati has hundreds of law firms that list personal injury as a service. Not all of them try cases in front of a jury, and not all of them focus on injury law full time. This guide looks at firms with a documented, verifiable track record in the practice area, so you know who you are actually calling.
1. O’Connor, Acciani & Levy
Focus: Personal injury, wrongful death, medical malpractice, workers’ compensation, Social Security Disability
O’Connor, Acciani & Levy has practiced personal injury law in Cincinnati since 1992. The firm has 11 attorneys and has built its reputation on contingency-fee representation, meaning clients pay nothing unless the firm recovers compensation.
Partner Barry D. Levy is a Board Certified Civil Trial Attorney through the National Board of Trial Advocacy, a credential that requires documented trial experience and peer review. The firm holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, the highest peer-rating standard that service offers, awarded in 2021. Several of the firm’s attorneys have also been named to the Ohio Super Lawyers list, a peer-nominated recognition covering the top 5% of attorneys in the state each year.
Client feedback backs this up. The firm’s Cincinnati office carries a 4.7-star average across roughly 1,350 Google reviews, a large enough sample to reflect a consistent client experience rather than a handful of outliers. The firm handles cases ranging from car and truck accidents to workplace injuries and wrongful death claims, and has represented clients across Ohio and Northern Kentucky for more than three decades.
Contact:
600 Vine Street, Suite 1600, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 241-7111
Website: oal-law.com
2. Phillips Law Firm, Inc.
Focus: Personal injury, civil litigation, business law
Founded in 1994 by attorney John H. Phillips, this firm has handled personal injury cases in the Cincinnati area for more than 25 years. Phillips has been named to the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, a group that recognizes attorneys who have won million-dollar-plus verdicts or settlements, and has been listed among Ohio Super Lawyers. The firm is smaller than some others on this list, which it markets as an advantage for direct attorney access.
Contact:
9521 Montgomery Road, Cincinnati, OH 45242
Phone: 513-985-2500
Website: phillipslawfirm.com
3. Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima
Focus: Personal injury, wrongful death, criminal defense
Founded in 1999, this firm reports more than 200 years of combined attorney experience and a history of multi-million-dollar verdicts and settlements in personal injury and wrongful death cases. The firm splits its practice between injury law and criminal defense, and operates out of six offices across southern Ohio and Northern Kentucky.
Contact:
3734 Eastern Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45226
Phone: 513-932-7375
Website: rittgers.com
4. Markovits, Stock & DeMarco, LLC
Focus: Personal injury, class actions, complex commercial litigation
This firm takes a different approach than the others on this list, focusing heavily on class action and mass tort litigation alongside individual personal injury cases. The firm reports more than $2 billion recovered for clients across its case history and has attorneys recognized by Ohio Super Lawyers. It is a good option specifically for cases tied to defective products or data breaches affecting multiple people, rather than a single-incident injury claim.
Contact:
119 East Court Street, Suite 530, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: 513-651-3700
Website: msdlegal.com
Why Practice-Area Experience Matters
Not every lawyer who accepts injury cases spends most of their time in court. A general practice attorney might handle a car accident claim between real estate closings and small business contracts. A dedicated personal injury attorney, by contrast, spends years learning the specific pressure points: how local judges handle motions, how Ohio insurance adjusters value claims, and what evidence holds up when a case actually goes to trial rather than settling early.
This is why credentials like an AV Preeminent rating, a Super Lawyers selection, or board certification through the National Board of Trial Advocacy matter. These are not self-issued titles. They involve peer review, documented case outcomes, or a formal certification process. When you are comparing lawyers, ask directly about their trial experience, not just their settlement history, since a firm’s willingness to take a case to trial often affects how seriously an insurance company negotiates in the first place.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to hire a personal injury lawyer in Cincinnati? Most personal injury firms in Cincinnati, including all four listed here, work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay no upfront fee, and the firm only gets paid a percentage of your recovery if your case succeeds. Ask any firm you contact to confirm their specific fee percentage in writing before signing an agreement.
How long do I have to file a personal injury claim in Ohio? Ohio generally gives injury victims two years from the date of the accident to file a lawsuit, though exceptions apply depending on the type of claim. Talk to an attorney as soon as possible, since evidence and witness memory fade quickly.
Do I need a lawyer if the insurance company already offered me a settlement? An early settlement offer is often based on the minimum the insurer thinks you will accept, not the full value of your claim. An attorney can review medical records, lost wages, and long-term care needs before you agree to anything final.
What is the difference between an AV Preeminent rating and a Super Lawyers listing? Both are peer-review recognitions, but they come from different organizations. AV Preeminent is issued by Martindale-Hubbell based on peer ratings of legal ability and ethics. Super Lawyers is a separate service that selects the top 5% of attorneys in a state each year through peer nomination and evaluation.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a personal injury lawyer in Cincinnati comes down to a few concrete questions: How long has the firm handled cases like yours? What do verified peer ratings and client reviews actually show? And will the attorney you hire go to trial if the insurance company will not offer a fair settlement? O’Connor, Acciani & Levy has answered those questions consistently for over three decades, with a documented trial record, a top peer rating, and a large base of client reviews to back it up. Whichever firm you choose from this list, confirm their experience with your specific type of case and ask clear questions about fees before you sign anything.
